Opinion
Women of the Partition
This article delves into the significance of post-colonial literature in contextualizing female migration.
The Partition of India in 1947 is a central historical event in the twentieth century that functions as a defining moment which is neither the ‘beginning nor end and continues to influence how the peoples and states of postcolonial South Asia envisage their past, present and future.’ Vital to this historical moment is its impact on the literature it produced which revealed a multitude of trajectories surrounding the tension within the subcontinent and among various religious communities, predominantly Hindu, Muslim and Sikh. More profoundly, post-Partition literature revealed a gendered reality that exposed a mass mistreatment of South Asian women at the expense of their patriarchal communities. Female narratives recounted the condition of women who were ruthlessly ostracized by, and vehemently attached to the emerging state, thereby becoming catalysts to understand the complexity entrenched within this injury. Novels such as Cracking India by Bapsi Sidwa, Pinjar by Amrita Pritam and Partitions by Amit Majmudar exposed first- hand experiences of women that have historically been lost in conventional accounts regarding migration and abduction.
Sidhwa, in her novel Cracking India narrates the life of Lenny Sethi, an eight-year-old girl from a wealthy Parsee family living in Lahore. Unaware of the Partition, Lenny questions the disturbing talk of how India is going to be broken, whether one can break a country and what happens if they break it where her house is? This anxiety is heightened once Lenny learns that Lahore would be part of Pakistan, angrily expressing, “I am Pakistani. In a snap. Just like that” and observes how “one day everybody is themselves – and the next day they are Hindu, Muslim, Sikh, Christian.” As Lenny stays stationary, her group of friends gradually separates from her due to their various religious backgrounds and slowly Lenny is exiled from them. Her involuntary shift to Pakistan which has created a loneliness within her has redefined home and made half of what was Lahore inaccessible. Without ever moving, she has migrated, and she rejects this forced Pakistani identity. Hence, she continues to stay hostile towards Lahore, even as she nears death.
Meanwhile, Pritam’s Pooro in “Pinjaar” is a young Hindu girl engaged to her neighbour, Ram Chandra, and is subsequently kidnapped in vengeance by a Muslim man, Rashida who forcefully converts, marries her, and renames her to Hamida. Consequently, Pooro is rejected from her family and resorts to bearing Rashida’s children whilst burying her former self. In Rashida’s home and village, Pooro feels an isolation and displacement, which produces a kind of sadist masochism that resists all efforts at reparation, acculturation, and assimilation. Gradually, Pritam shifts to addressing Hamida in her text instead of Pooro, confirming the migration is absolute, and Pooro’s exile is made permanent both, geographically and communally on the Pakistani side of Punjab with a Muslim husband and his children.
The novelty of this migration is that it has occurred through abduction hence, there is neither any agency in her movement nor any in her condition. Every sentiment is pronounced with an underlying accusation for in its happening, abduction has not only kidnapped Pooro of a family and an existing community, but also usurped her decision to choose refugee-dom. This mode of migration, an architype quite familiar to the women of the Partition, creates an involuntary
movement that is unrecognized by the state and perpetuates a culture of forced captivity that is excused when performed in conjunction to religion and borders.
Additionally, Simran Kaur from Majmudar’s Partitions is a young Sikh woman whose father has murdered her mother and sisters in fear of the approaching Muslims and is now manipulating her to commit suicide. For him, the approaching enemy poses two vivid threats: a loss of patriarchal control over the purity of his Sikh daughter and the wrath of his community whose lineage is threatened by the Muslims capturing Simran. In order to protect his bloodline from being contaminated and fearing a loss of authority, Simran’s father creates a state of guilt championed by the migrating patriarchal Sikh community that lives around them which observes suicide as a ritual, a sacred act, that will prevent excommunication and become a means of divine survival.
The novelty of this migration is that it has occurred through abduction hence, there is neither any agency in her movement nor any in her condition.
However, Simran disregards her father’s fears and becomes a catalyst for female agency at a time when it was least recognized: she chooses to live and since feminine existence on disputed land ‘is considered a deeply sacrilegious act of rebellion, defiance and dissent,’ Simran is thrust into exile for merely ‘asking for such a privilege.’ Still, Simran’s father tries to poison her, upon which, she runs away from home and although her migration is not through abduction, it is still forced, and it has created a state of exile which generates a crippling sorrow of estrangement. By enacting on reason, and escaping from home, she is not only displaced within the Sikh community, but also becomes a threat to both, Sikhism and Sikh masculinity as she is now open to prey. Hence, her exile becomes so absolute that for her, destiny is a desire for death – a divine end without kill.
Amidst the anxieties of the Partition war, the three authors highlight female defiance as core feminine agency. While Sidhwa introduces us to a stationary provincial migration that is suffered quite solely at the hands of the state, Majmudar and Pritam weave the impact of a captured and forced movement that is propagated by religious communities. As they resist and survive the forced migrations thrust upon them, Lenny, Pooro and Simran reject a twice displacement and continue to exist.
These post-Partition women, in their lived realities experience what I coin as the Partition- condition that creates within them a state of terminal loss wherein they suffer the entire spectrum of exile and refugeehood without the core agency to perform a wilful migration. Within this rootlessness, that is suffered in silence and experienced in solitude, Lenny, Pooro and Simran create a remembrance of a common desire to return home, an extinct site that has been carved in oblivion and suffering the causality of lost communities. For the women of the Partition, post- colonial literature visualizes the severity of statehood, and the price of independence. Quite vividly, it portrays how the living expression of the nation is the moving consciousness of the women of the carved territories.
The writer holds an undergraduate degree in Literary Studies from Eugene Lang College of Liberal Arts at The New School and an MPhil in South Asian Studies from the University of Cambridge.
HBL contributes over Rs 4 bn. in Social Uplift
Pakistan’s Hamza Khan becomes World Junior Squash Champion
US Centcom chief meets COAS Gen. Asim Munir
NBP enters into an agreement with NRTC
ChatGPT dragged to US court
US diplomat briefed on Gandhara civilisation
Telenor Pakistan partners with Kistpay to scale smartphone financing
EFU Life appoints new MD and CEO
Princess Diana’s sweater to be auctioned
Top BBC Presenter Off the Air
Yamuna laps Taj Mahal walls
Sirajuddin Aziz appointed as Banking Ombudsman
Jashn-e-Urdu Held in Chicago
Afghan women protest against beauty parlour ban
Summit rebrands itself as Bank Makramah
Auction of old Washington chancery building called into question
Rehmat Ali Hasnie Appointed as President of National Bank of Pakistan
My grandmother migrated from Punjab and used to tell us stories of her past. This makes me think of what went through her mind when she used to miss her friends and family. Please provide email of the author, I would like to read more
Very interesting read the author writes brilliantly.
This writer has wonderfully captured the other side of the coin. Women are always neglected and I am so touched to see them represented
Dear Zain Qadeer
Please contact the author further on fathimahsheikh@gmail.com. The author also has a weekly column on the Friday Times: https://www.thefridaytimes.com/author/fathima-sheikh/
Well written 👏🏼