Karachi
The Right Balance
When parent-child friendship is practiced with clear boundaries, it produces a
household where both parties are mindful of their responsibilities.

In both form and substance, parenting styles vary across cultures and socio-economic strata. We can average these to two major approaches: the “my way or the highway” style popular in Asian societies, and the “buddy” attitude predominant in the West.
While all parenting styles converge on raising emotionally healthy and independent adults, no consensus exists among experts on an optimal blueprint. The truth thus is far more complex than we perceive.
Let’s review two contrasting opinions to this effect. A New Hampshire University study in 2012 found parents who practice strict child-rearing invariably raise unruly and disobedient children.
Conversely, Dr. Martin Stephen in a Lancashire Post article in March 2018 bemoaned the “buddy syndrome” among parents as responsible for the same outcomes. He stressed parents must act as authority figures and not friends for their children’s greater good.
Naturally, such divisive opinions do little to clarify matters for parents. So what should they do? To answer this question, we must first distinguish between the two approaches and uncover a reasonable middle ground.
Asian parents typically prefer to exercise absolute authority on their children’s lives. They base this preference on the notion that children are young and naïve. Likewise, they expect them to accept this dominance unquestioningly in their best interests.
Parenting is a tough gig at the best of times and only gets tougher as children navigate through adolescence.
Often, parents who choose the opposite tack find themselves accused of neglect and harmful permissiveness. But aspiring to befriend your children is not bad parenting, as this allows family bonds to root deeper.
Critics of parent-child friendship wrongly deduce that such a relationship implies “no rules and all play.” When practiced with clear boundaries, it produces a household where both parties are mindful of their responsibilities. So, even when the family steps out for, say, ice-cream in the evening, this does not excuse children from completing their homework.
I believe parents should absolutely befriend their children because this bond will enrich their family lives. But it’s also important to strike a healthy balance between discussion and dictation.
Arriving at the right mix of authority and camaraderie, of ordering and listening, is difficult and will demand tweaks over time, but I’m certain parents will find their efforts rewarding.
The immense value of this friendship lies in expanding our definition of parenting beyond the oft-quoted. Past standard-issue guidance and advice, parents must realize their children need someone to confide to when they feel claustrophobic of the world around them.
Even if they don’t befriend their offspring and instead embrace the even-keeled authoritative style, which some experts recommend, they must be accessible and always willing to lend a sympathetic ear.
We know parenting is a tough gig at the best of times and only gets tougher as children navigate through adolescence. They face emotional peaks and valleys that we must manage tactfully if they’re not to scar for life. Hence nurturing an open and communicative relationship is vital.
Children at any age can slump into depression if they cannot confide in someone they love and respect. While friends may occasionally fulfill this role, nothing substitutes for parental involvement.
That said, patronizing them in such confessionals can backfire spectacularly. Avoid the “I told you so” tone and, if possible, just listen and empathize, as most of the time children can solve their own problems. We should acknowledge that no matter what their age, children pine for compassionate parents.
Dictatorial parenting may also stymie independent problem-solving and emotional intelligence in children when they’re used to being spoon-fed solutions. But if we foster in them piecemeal the ability to think critically, they will develop into productive adults.
When a dicey problem presents itself, and it always does, don’t jump into micromanager mode and instead patiently answer their questions while nudging them along the right track. Equally important is to keep these exchanges conversational and not adversarial, for the latter may sow in them rebellion and provoke misbehaviour, so what they gain is a false sense of autonomy.
Those opposed to this parenting strategy argue children raised in such households are mutinous and undisciplined as, as adults, struggle to fit into workplaces and society at large. They also contend parents are reluctant to dive deep into their children’s worlds as they toil through their own burdens and obligations.
While the above criticisms may be partially valid, often these outcomes result from an irresponsive parent-child relationship. Parents instinctively adopt the carrot-and-stick approach with children without attempting to uncover the roots of their problematic behaviour. They set rules in stone without explanation and without allowing for their input. This status quo, above all else, leads to delinquency.
To summarize, parenting is an exercise in fluidity and evolution. It is impossible to always be your child’s best friend or a strict taskmaster. The key is to reach a situation-specific balance, and if parents do this they will discover that its benefits to familial harmony are boundless. ![]()
The author is an early childhood educator and editor of www.imageofachild.com. She can be reached at imageofachild@gmail.com |
|
Cover Story
|
|
Special Editorial Feature
|
|
News Buzz
|
Update |


Leave a Reply