The future of Pakistan and the U.S. diplomatic relationship holds challenges and opportunities shaped by geopolitical dynamics and shared strategic interests. Historically, the relationship has been complex, influenced by counterterrorism cooperation, regional stability, and economic ties. Theodore Craig, a retired U.S. diplomat with extensive experience in Pakistan, presents a compelling narrative in his book “Pakistan and American Diplomacy: Insights from 9/11 to the Afghanistan Endgame.”
From 9/11 to the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, Craig offers a unique perspective shaped by his tenure in Islamabad. His analysis is framed around the 2019 Cricket World Cup, using the tournament as a backdrop to explore Pakistan’s relations with key nations like Afghanistan, India, and the U.K.
The book delves into Pakistan’s diplomatic history since independence in 1947, illuminating its relationships with the U.S., China, India, Sri Lanka, and Afghanistan. Drawing on his diplomatic career and insights from Washington, Craig critically examines the policy decisions leading up to the fall of the Kabul government in 2021, providing a balanced view of the ensuing consequences. He situates US-Pakistan relations within the broader context of promoting democracy and combating terrorism post-Cold War.
In his own words, “Pakistan is a large, troubled, geographically vital state. For geopolitical reasons rather than sentiment, we should continue to engage its compromised governments and resourceful people. We have more to gain than lose from such a strategy, whatever our real and lingering hard feelings from the post-9/11 decades.”
Craig’s writing is informed by his firsthand experiences and offers nuanced perspectives on South Asian geopolitics. He navigates complex issues with clarity, offering sharp insights into the shortcomings of policies pursued by Pakistan, India, and the U.S. in the region. His affection for Pakistan and its cricket culture is evident, yet he maintains a critical stance on security policies.
Critics have praised Craig’s book for its depth and accessibility. It is a valuable resource for students and diplomacy practitioners, thoroughly examining the political and diplomatic landscape in the aftermath of significant global events. His call for renewed development assistance to Pakistan focused on sustainable economic growth, underscores his commitment to promoting feasible U.S. policy options in the region.
Regional dynamics will shape the U.S.-Pakistan relationship. Pakistan’s relations with China, India, and Afghanistan will influence U.S. policy decisions. Balancing these relationships while advancing mutual interests in regional stability and development will require diplomatic finesse and strategic alignment. Human rights and governance issues remain sensitive topics. The U.S. has often raised concerns about democracy, human rights abuses, and freedom of expression in Pakistan. How these issues are addressed will affect the depth of bilateral ties. Pakistan’s role in Afghanistan post-US withdrawal will be crucial. Both countries have overlapping interests in ensuring Afghanistan does not become a haven for terrorism.
Overall, the book “Pakistan and American Diplomacy: Insights from 9/11 to the Afghanistan Endgame” by Theodore Craig stands out as a comprehensive and insightful exploration of US-Pakistan relations. The book contributes to the understanding of Pakistan’s foreign policy and challenges conventional wisdom with its astute analysis and constructive recommendations for the future.
In place of a bittersweet relationship oscillating between ‘with us’ or ‘against us’ perceptions, fostering a relationship based on mutual respect, cooperation, and shared goals will be essential for Pakistan and the U.S. Both nations have the opportunity to build on areas of convergence, such as counterterrorism, economic development, and regional stability, while addressing areas of divergence through constructive dialogue and engagement.
Leave a Reply