Legacy of Oppression
True progress requires truly visionary leadership.
Though Pakistan and India have achieved independence, the legacy of the British colonial era continues to this day. The colonial masters followed the policy of divide and rule. The bureaucracy was structured in such a way that it would suppress the masses; they also loved luxurious lifestyles at the expense of the colonised people exploitation of all sorts was their favourite pastime so that they could continue their unchallenged hegemony. This legacy was inherited by the ruling elite of India and Pakistan from their colonial masters and is a source of the poor socio-economic growth of the region.
The British Raj devised everything to sustain its rule in the subcontinent. It divided the people on the basis of their faith, social status, etc. Those seeds of discord continue to bleed the subcontinent with more hatred than ever before. The unsettled issue of Kashmir, which is the unfinished agenda of the partition of the subcontinent according to the UN Security Council Resolutions, is a legacy of the British Raj. There are many more such issues.
It was a calculated move to keep the people of the region engaged in a state of perpetual conflict, based on the notion “if they will not be allowed to rule, people should not live in peace”. The tendency to acquire more and more territory by means of force is being practised by the BJP-led Modi regime, disregarding bilateral agreements such as the Simla Agreement of 1972, the para 1 (ii) of which says, “…. pending the final settlement of any of the problems between the two countries, neither side shall unilaterally alter the situation….”. This is the legacy of the British Raj through which they forcibly annexed territories of the weak nations or wherever they deemed necessary. The Indian government has all through trampled on the will of the people of Kashmir. Bilateral agreements, the Lahore Declaration of 1999 and the resolutions of the Security Council were thrown into the dustbin of history. While the Congress Party of India succeeded in dismembering Pakistan and creating Bangladesh, the BJP has abrogated India’s own constitution and unilaterally merged the Muslim-majority state of Kashmir into its union territory.
British inherited institutions have always flourished in the subcontinent as they were modeled on the concept of suppression of the masses. The colonisers shaped the bureaucratic structure to suppress the people rather than to render service to them. They did this so that in case an uprising erupted, the bureaucracy could use violent tactics to silence the agitators. It is for this reason that use of force became an inherent tool for the bureaucracy in Pakistan even after partition. Archaic and brutal tactics used by police for extracting confessions from suspects have been handed down by the colonial masters. In a recent case, Salahuddin, who mocked the CCTV camera while stealing from an ATM in Faisalabad, was picked up by law enfocement agencies from Rahim Yar Khan. Their brutal torture caused the death of this mentally challenged person. Through the whole process, the police performed the job of complainant, prosecutor and judge.
It was an utter surprise when the IG of the Punjab Police issued an order prohibiting police officials from using mobile phones or taking photographs during duty hours. Can this measure change the behaviour of the police force? Will not using mobile phones and cameras make the police more professional? Was this one of those long-awaited police reforms? During the tenure of former chief minister Shahbaz Sharif, the uniform of the Punjab police was changed in the hope that the changed uniform would change the public’s perception about the police force. Millions of rupees were spent on the new uniforms. The same money could have been spent on capacity building and creating awareness in the police about their responsibilities of being service-oriented.
A change in mindset is what is needed for the police department. This requires conscious efforts and deployment of resources in a logcal manner. All underlying issues need to be addressed, such as increasing salaries, performance-based promotions, etc., rather than such cosmetic actions as uniform change or banning mobile phones and cameras in police stations.
A change in mindset is what is needed for the police department. This requires conscious efforts and deployment of resources in a logcal manner. All underlying issues need to be addressed, such as increasing salaries, performance-based promotions, etc., rather than such cosmetic actions as uniform change or banning mobile phones and cameras in police stations.
Prime Minister Imran Khan says colonisers enjoyed luxurious lifestyles and lived in large mansions. The same people lived within their limited means and could not afford luxuries as taxpayers in England. That legacy has been transferred into the DNA of the bureaucratic and political classes of the subcontinent. Ruling rather than providing service has become a routine for them.
It is these colonial traits that are responsible for the backwardness of Pakistan which is far behind many countries that attained independence in the late 1940s. It is still facing the problems which existed at the time of independence as there is a lack of visionary leadership which would have thought of the well-being of the people, prosperity of the country and strengthening of institutions. The ruling elite have inherited the same colonial mindset and have maintained the status quo because it has helped them to sustain their rule and has sent the people to grapple with one issue after another. Pakistan is a cash-strapped nation but its politicians, its bureaucracy and the people at large indulge in wasteful expenses of all kinds. When there is more expenditure and less income, this creates corruption and leads the nation to a vicious debt-trap, which is a serious hindrance in the path of socio-economic progress and self-sustenance.
It is time for wise choices to be made so that a direction can be set towards national prosperity through honest politicians, service-oriented bureaucracy and working institutions. The law needs to be followed in letter and spirit rather than for mere lip service. Sustainable institutions must be made viable to save more Salahuddins from falling victim to the police.![]()
The writer is a development sector practitioner and can be reached at amjadsiyal@hotmail.com |
|
Cover Story
|
|
Interview
|
|
Around Town
|
|
Tribute
|
Update
|


Leave a Reply