Cover Story
Fight for the Soul
A third consecutive victory will further embolden Narendra Modi, who is not only inspired by rising Christian fascism in the USA and Europe and Zionist fascism in Israel but is also encouraged by these like-minded allies to turn India into a hellhole for minorities.
Undoubtedly, the National Congress Party, India’s oldest Party that held the strings of power for decades, now finds itself in an existential crisis. Can the Indian National Congress rejuvenate itself and become a serious contender for power in the forthcoming general elections in 2024? Will Congress, under the leadership of Rahul Gandhi, be able to seize the opportunity to re-energize and position itself by presenting a strong ideological alternative to Brand Modi of Hindu nationalism and contribute to the defense of Indian democracy? These are questions that evade clear answers.
A few months from now, India will hold the most consequential election in its history, which may be the last chance to stop Modi from transforming the world’s largest democracy into a fascist Hindu-supremacist state. With the Congress Party’s electoral successes in some state elections in which the BJP suffered defeats, a glimmer of hope and a faint possibility is emerging that the Indian National Congress might recover some of its lost ground and may have an outside chance of forming a government with its allies and coalition partners. This prospect gets a further boost with some key regional opposition parties forming alliances with the Congress Party to create a united opposition to challenge Modi.
Congress received only 19% of the vote in the 2014 and 2019 general elections. Congress, therefore, requires a fresh and innovative manifesto to challenge the BJP and Hindu-chauvinist ideology. This requires a party leader who understands the aspirations of young Indians and convinces the electorate that Congress is the only party that can retrieve India from the verge of descending into the dark pit of a fascist Hindu state and put it back on track. Whether Rahul Gandhi will succeed in articulating a positive and aspirational vision for the country’s future remains to be seen.
The resurgence of the Congress Party with a compelling narrative that appeals to the youth, the persecuted minorities, and a large number of silent and sane Hindu voters tired of the BJP’s authoritarian and increasingly divisive governance style and who aspire to see a secular, peaceful and prosperous India is not an impossibility. Since its inception, Congress has been resilient and able to remodel, change, and adapt to shifting political circumstances. India watchers and experts feel that Congress is the only political party comparable to BJP’s national and organizational status. Suppose Congress can overcome its internal organization issues and leadership problems and rise like a phoenix from its ashes. In that case, it still has the capability and popular appeal to, if not win the elections in 2024, at least provide a credible and formidable opposition able to oppose Modi’s growing fascism.
At the moment, it would not be wrong to say that the BJP controls the political narrative in India. However, Rahul Gandhi’s Bharat Jodo Yatra and the formation of the Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance (INDIA) are making waves and forcing the BJP to consider this emerging trend seriously. The 28 opposition parties allied in June and are challenging Modi’s party on its economic record, rising unemployment, and other domestic problems, including growing anti-Muslim sentiment. The alliance has decided to work out seat-sharing arrangements to stop the ruling BJP party’s third straight win.
A joint resolution adopted by INDIA promises to uphold the idea of India as enshrined in the Constitution, ensures the rights of socially, educationally, and economically backward communities, and ensures a fair census of the caste, including the lower form. This is an element of concern for the BJP as it can develop into a strong narrative to counter Modi’s fascist model. Usually, the BJP has gained from a three-way contest. However, the emergence of INDIA will effectively turn the 2024 election into a two-way contest, which should be a matter of concern for the BJP despite its current popularity.
The enabling environment in the 21st century, with an implosion of mass media and new technologies and platforms for social interaction, has facilitated the resurgence of personality cult leaders who, in the garb of nationalism, have perpetrated heinous crimes against their opponents, as we see being done by the BJP leader Modi in India, particularly against the Muslims.
What is even more tragic is that leaders like Modi, through populism, provoking religious sensitivities, inciting latent fears, and exploiting the underlying fissures in society, manage to gather steam and ride on a wave of popularity. Based on negativity, Modi has managed to capture political and administrative power and put in place his goons at the helm of affairs, including in ministerial and administrative strong positions, with the judiciary lamely following suit and obliging. Even though, like Modi, these are convicted criminals who are iconized not only by their cult following but also aided by the full potential of the political, economic, administrative, and judicial apparatus to put them on a pedestal as saviors of the nation.
In India, Modi has created a personality cult around him. Despite bad governance and several political setbacks, Modi’s charisma and popularity helped the BJP return to power in the 2019 elections. BJP sought votes only in Modi’s name and won. This has created a fascist monster using his personality cult’s influence to destroy India’s secular fabric and create a Hindu state. Inspired by Modi’s policy of hate, otherization, exclusion, and fanaticism, his blind followers are playing havoc with the hapless minorities of India, particularly the Muslims.
Despite all these atrocities, Modi’s ideology of strident Hindu nationalism, combined with promises of economic development, remains a big draw with voters in India. With the next general election around the corner, Modi is already in pole position and is projecting himself as a “lone worrier” against many opposition parties who all want to remove him from power. This was evident from his recent statement in the upper house of parliament when he roared that the nation witnessed how an individual was firmly facing many, thus setting the tone for the 2024 elections. Modi is appealing to the voters on the slogan that he was living for the country, and it suits BJP to have this narrative of one leader taking on the fight with a long list of opposition leaders - Modi versus the rest.
The youth of India see Modi as a strong leader who rose to lead the largest democracy in the world from humble beginnings as a tea vendor. The local flavour that Modi provides by wearing the traditional dress and speaking in Hindi both at home and abroad makes the youth relate to him, and he has become an inspirational hero to be emulated. There seems to be merit in the Indian Home Minister’s statement that there were no competitors to Modi and that the Indian nation was solidly behind Modi. Whether this is the usual political bluster before elections will only be proven when people come to vote. Still, for the moment, it is advantageous for Modi for the 2024 general elections.
Given the popularity of Modi, at the moment, the political outlook for the Indian National Congress looks frail. Congress cannot afford to neglect and misread the political pulse of the Indian electorate. Its supporters and opponents are carefully watching what Congress can achieve to save the Indian democracy from becoming a sham and the Indian constitution from being trashed and ripped off its core value of Secularism.
If Congress and its allies fail, the 2024 general elections in India will present a political scenario that will not look immensely different from today’s. A third consecutive victory will further embolden Modi, who is not only inspired by rising Christian fascism in the USA and Europe and Zionist fascism in Israel but is also encouraged by these like-minded allies to turn India into a hellhole for minorities further. As one of the India watchers aptly put it, this is a “do or die” situation for the Congress party.
The writer served as Ambassador of Pakistan to China, European Union, Belgium, Luxembourg and Ireland, from 1993 to 2020. She can be reached at naghmanahashmi40@gmail.com
Khalid Ahmed Brings Back Memories of Zia Mohyeddin
HBL and J.P. Morgan Enter into an Agreement
India arrests top Vivo executives
NBP announces pilot launch of ‘Digital Account Opening’
Khaleda Zia at ‘high risk of death’
RSF condemns detention of Kashmiri journalist
Cricket set for shot at Olympic glory
Frank Sinatra in Karachi
Maldives’ new president wants Indian troops out of country
Arundhati Roy faces prosecution
Pakistan makes history at 2026 FIFA WC qualifiers
South Asia, the world’s most disconnected region
X social media to test $1 annual subscription
Nutshell turns 20
Bombay court rejects petition to ban Pakistani Artistes
PIA switches to plan B
Leave a Reply