International
‘Break Their Bone’
The Israeli genocidal act in Gaza is being projected as a normal war as if Palestinians have no historical and geographical association with the territory and their right of self-determination is hollow rhetoric without any ancestral or genealogical claim.
The Israel-Gaza war has already entered into its seventh month with all possibility of further expansion in the near future as Israeli killing machines continue to roll over the innocent Palestinians. In the span of last seven months, around 35,000 people in Gaza, often described as the largest open-air prison, have been killed, and hundreds of thousands are either wounded or maimed, which is the continuation of Yitzhak Rabin’s “Break Their Bone” doctrine experimented during first Intifada in 1988. According to one estimate, one Palestinian has lost a limb every three minutes since the war broke out on October 7, 2023. Perhaps the Gaza genocide is the first such massacre in history, which is being broadcast live uninterrupted through numerous social media forums, while many are enjoying it as a horror TV drama while the rest are showing their grief. In any violence, the first death is counted as the real death, and what follows is merely the numbers, and this epithet is aptly reflected in today’s Gaza.
The world is not witnessing the Muslim massacre for the first time, as history is laden with such genocides of Muslims. One can recall the killing of hundreds of thousands of Bosnian Muslims in the last decade of the 20th century, and again, the ethnic cleansing of Muslim Rohingyas by the Myanmar Junta is not a secret. The atrocities against millions of Uighur Muslims in Chinese internment camps are not so different from a genocidal act. Bitter memories of French colonial rule still hound Muslims in Algeria, Morocco, and Tunisia. Iraqis and Afghans are still struggling to elude the image of the fearful presence of the U.S. The French colonial masters normalised the colonial conquest of Algeria and subsequent genocide by depicting it as a return of the Roman Empire and recovery of Roman land, which today resonates in the Zionist dictum of return to their Promised Biblical Land and call by the Israeli Rabbi for the killing Palestinian men, women, and children to fulfill the teaching of Jewish law book, Halakha.
Today, Gaza seems to have become an epicenter of Muslim cleansing, which is not only rooted in historical and religious hatred of Zionist Jews and Christian Zionists toward Muslims but has been further galvanized by the rise of Islamophobia, which is reflected in the killing of Palestinians.
Demonising Palestinians as human animals by Israeli Défense Minister Gallant is an expression of a genocidal mindset, and a further call by Israeli minister Ben Gvir for an all-out execution of Palestinian prisoners in Israel jails can only be seen through the prism of the genocidal design of Israel and its Western collaborators. The animal metaphor and metaphor of virtue versus evil are deeply rooted in Zionist philosophy, which sees Palestinians as a source of all evil.
French President Emmanuel Macron, soon after Israel began bombarding Gaza, called for the mobilisation of the anti-ISIS-like coalition to eliminate Hamas to shift the focus from the death of thousands of innocent children and women.
One can see how the sites of hospitals tuning onto graveyards and missiles ripping into infants and accompanied by the global outcry against Israel and its supporters failed to shake their conscience. Today’s ghastly silence on the part of the Western countries is another reinforcement of the statement of late U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright when she had remarked that ‘the price is worth’ when asked about the death of half of a million Iraqi children due to Western sanction. Meanwhile, it is also worth noticing how the death of seven aid workers of World Central Kitchen in an Israeli attack in Gaza was followed by an all-out criticism of Prime Minister Netanyahu by all right-to-left governments. Still, the death of 40,000 Palestinians is the embodiment of the right to self-defense. Presider Biden even called the founder of World Central Kitchen and offered his condolence and no world of remorse for the massacre of innocent men and women in Palestine as if the extermination of Palestinians is forgivable as long as the killers are Israelis. Palestinian non-violent marches and protests are entirely ignored or demonised by Western powers. On the contrary, the use of phosphorous on civilians and the burning of villages belonging to Palestinians receive protection from Western countries in many tangible and intangible ways.
The apathy of Western collaborators towards the Israeli genocide of Palestinians is well embodied in their repeated pledge to Israel of all military and economic assistance and exceptional diplomatic support in the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) in compensation for the butchery of men, women, and children, which has rendered the whole of Gaza into a Ghost Valley.
It is not only that the Gaza genocide over the weeks has stopped making headlines in the newspapers, but now the whole discourse seems to have shifted to whether and when the Israeli forces will launch its-much-awaited Refah operation and if the Western countries could prevent Israel from expanding its war into Lebanon, Syria, or even Iran.
If a handful of displaced Gazans are allowed to return to their devastated lands, it is being commended as a sign of leniency and display of Israeli democratic ethos without any accountability for the killing of over 35,000 people. Now, the world community is pleading with Israel to ease the border restriction for the delivery of more aid. If Israel allows entry of a few additional trucks, it is being celebrated as an act of concession and compassion, forgetting its commitment to the worst sort of crime against humanity, despite all calls by the International Court of Justice and the UNSC to stop genocide and immediate ceasefire.
Recently, there has been a further blip in the coverage of the Gaza genocide when the international community began talking of post-Hamas Gaza governance and whether the governance of Gaza would be handed over to the Palestinian Authority, overlooking the fact that the internally displaced would come back to their ruined homes. Before talking of future governance of Gaza, the displaced people should be allowed to rebuild their lives with dignity, but Israel or its collaborators do none of this. No one is talking of the education, employment, food security, and healthcare of those who have been routed off their ancestral homes, and, if they come back, what future they would have after their agricultural land has been turned into rock amidst constant bombardment. Israel has always adopted a conflict management approach in dealing with the Palestinians, and as long as Palestinians can bear the brunt of violence, the status quo will continue. That is how the occasional genocide is made look normal, and all Palestinians are sought to serve in maintaining the status quo.
This is how the normalisation of the genocide looks like today in Gaza, which is not different from past endeavors exercised in the case of other genocides. Since its inception, the portrayal of the Gaza genocide as Israel’s right to self-defence seems to have become a sacred duty of all the collaborators of Israel. Recently, The New York Times reportedly instructed its staffers covering Gaza to avoid calling the massacres a genocide or ethnic cleansing and even not use the term occupied territories while talking of Palestine. The staff members reporting on Gaza have also been asked to refrain from mentioning the word ‘Palestine.’ This is how the Israeli genocidal act is being projected as a normal war between state and anti-state militias as if Palestinians have no historical and geographical association with the territory and their right of self-determination is hollow rhetoric without any ancestral or genealogical claim.
In a given situation, it seems the world has moved on, and one should harbor no apprehension that the ongoing Muslim genocide, too, would be forgotten with the fact that genocide in slow motion will continue. Here I am reminded of Elie Wilson, who, while accepting the 1986 Nobel Peace Prize, had said that the place where men and women are killed because of their race or religion should become the center of the universe, but I doubt if Gaza will remain the focus of the universe for a long time.
Based in New Delhi, India, the author is a political analyst. He holds Ph.D. in International Politics and can be reached at fazzur@gmail.com
Pakistan urges Afghanistan to address terrorism as ‘shared concern’
New Team at PBA
Pakistan seeks investment, not loans: PM
Pakistan, China to form WG on 5 new economic corridors
ChatGPT sees a surge in website traffic as schools reopen
US diplomat visits Napa
Sarah Ahmad wins prestigious award
Pakistan eyes $300m by selling Panda Bonds
Tunnel becomes the latest flashpoint in India-China border tensions
India’s ‘Silicon Valley’ is running out of water
New Delhi summons US diplomat over Kejriwal’s arrest remarks
World’s super rich attend pre-wedding bash of Mukesh Ambani’s son
Shahid Afridi and Mushtaq Ahmed Demand Censorship
Biden, Netanyahu hold first call in over a month
Telenor Pakistan launches female sales trainee program
NBP’s Annual Corporate Briefing
Sailor martyred in operation against Indian fishermen
Leave a Reply