Cover Story
In the 75 year history of Pakistan since its creation in 1947, except 1971, never before had the country encountered such a dangerous political and economic crisis as it is going through now. Threatening the very foundations of Pakistan the year 2022 witnessed grave political instability and economic meltdown. Even then, there is no plausible roadmap for pulling the country from the brink of disaster, jeopardizing the present and future of some 220 million people of this country.
Those who are wielding power and are so-called custodians of the country seem to have let the people down because of their irresponsible, unprofessional and imprudent handling of issues which reflected poor management of political and economic crisis. From the engineered vote of no-confidence against former prime minister Imran Khan to finally bringing regime change on April 11, 2022, there has been no let-up in political crisis, imperilling economy, governance and the rule of law.
Is there a silver lining or light at the end of tunnel for a better present and future of Pakistan? How there can be a plausible roadmap for achieving political and economy stability? What are the impediments which derail the process of managing political crisis and economic degeneration? From any standpoint, there is a close linkage between politics and economics and if the former is in dire straits, it negatively impacts on the country’s economy. Those who engineered vote of no-confidence against the then prime minister Imran Khan and ousted him from power should have redeemed the consequences in terms of growing political schism and economic instability. Greed for power and focus on personal gains rather than national interest is their mode of thinking which augmented Pakistan’s economic vulnerability to the extent of sovereign default and eventual collapse.
The ensuing political crisis in Punjab in the shape of vote of confidence and no-confidence against the incumbent chief minister, horse trading to win the support of members of rival political parties, polarization in Karachi in the elections of local bodies and demand of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) for an early elections reflect myopic political parties who are only interested in power politics, instead of resolving critical issues confronting about 220 million people of Pakistan. Now, when Punjab’s Chief Minister obtained vote of confidence from provincial assembly on January 12 and subsequently dissolved the assembly, one can expect prevailing political crisis in the country to take a new shape.
As a sequel to political instability followed by regime change in April 2022, the economy of Pakistan was caught in the vicious cycle of default. Four major indications of the economic default are: lowest level of foreign exchange reserves capable of meeting only three weeks of imports; failure to make payments to friendly countries of the amount which they had kept with the State Bank of Pakistan; failure to honour letter of credit (LC) of several hundred million dollars and to open new LC’s causing severe crisis of raw materials, medicines and other essential items; the shocking statement of Federal Finance Minister Mr. Ishaq Dar stating that instead of 4.5 billion dollars, the country has 10 billion dollars of foreign exchange reserves, but in reality, 5.5 billion dollars are with private banks not with the State Bank. It is suspected that the government is resorting to amount of dollars kept in private banks to pay for imports and meet international obligations.
It bears mention that that when Pakistan conducted nuclear tests on May 28, 1998, the then government immediately froze foreign currency accounts of about 11 billion dollars because it had used the bulk of that amount to pay for imports. ‘The great bank robbery’ attributing to the freezing of foreign currency accounts shattered the trust of people on the government, and for a long period of time foreign currency accounts were not allowed to open. Now, unlike 1998 when 11 billion dollars were kept in foreign currency account, presently there are 5.5 billion dollars which the government cannot touch. But, unlike the statement of federal finance ministry official that the money of customers in foreign currency accounts is safe, there is no evidence that the government has not spent 5.5 billion dollars of private account holders. Growing trust deficit of people on governmental policies is a major source of economic meltdown in Pakistan.
A plausible roadmap to political and economic stability in Pakistan cannot be devised in a vacuum but would require four measures with a time span of ten years. First, eradication of the VVIP culture, adherence to merit, good governance, accountability and the rule of law. But who is going to do all such things particularly when from bottom to top and vice-versa the culture of corruption, inefficiency, laziness and inefficiency is deep–rooted? History is replete with examples that when a country is going down the hill and is about to collapse, it can only be saved by people who are above self-interest and not after perks, privileges and greed for power.
Honestly speaking, currently there is no indication of such type of a leadership taking place because of dearth of people who are bold, courageous, honest, and clear-headed with time management skills and imbued with both short and long-term vision. The feudal mindset having authoritarian culture is still the norm which is reflected in the attitude and behaviour of elites who wield power since the inception of Pakistan. Second, military establishment must be realistic and pragmatic in their thinking and way of life because this country cannot afford their further interference in politics and statecraft. Engineered vote of no confidence against the PTI government last year in April further exposed the military of looking the other way when its ‘favourite’ Imran Khan was ousted from power. Hypocrisy and contradiction in the narrative of Imran Khan against the then Chief of Army Staff General Qamar Javed Bajwa holding him responsible for covertly supporting the PDM-led vote of no-confidence and conspiring against his government since he got extension in the fall of 2019 cannot be denied but open blame against military establishment by the former prime minister reflected widespread criticism against generals who are held responsible for generating prevailing political and economic crisis.
Finally, the new leadership has a chance to be at the helm of affairs because general elections are due soon.
The PML (N) in the recent past also carried anti-military establishment narrative blaming the then COAS General Bajwa and the then Chief of the ISI Lt. Gen Faiz Hameed of openly supporting the PTI regime. But, according to Imran Khan, secret deal was reached between General Bajwa and PML (N) in 2021 to oust Imran Khan’s government from power. On this account, it is argued that military is part of the problem than part of the solution because since the assassination of Pakistan’s first prime minister Liaquat Ali Khan in October 1951 it is involved in politics and staged four coup d’état to overthrow civilian government. Even while out of power, military pulled strings from behind as it is alleged today. Strong narrative is prevailing these days that unless military’s intervention in politics is stopped, Pakistan can neither achieve political nor economic stability.
Third, the mindset which shapes perceptions of elites in Pakistan also needs to be changed because unrealistic approach to deal with political, economic and foreign policy issues will plunge the country further in the vicious cycle of crisis. To pull Pakistan from the brink of economic disaster and political instability, a wholesome approach needs to be pursued by those who wield power where the focus is not on self but national interest. The culture of merit, rule of law, accountability and better work ethics must be given preference rather than pursuing a policy of indifference on issue which tend to move Pakistan as a failed state.
As things stand today in Pakistan, the year 2023 will be like a make or break moment for the country because decisive measures are required by those who matter in terms of dealing with widespread frustration, pessimism and gloom about the present and future of this country. Cosmetic measures will not help because time is not on their side and the country needs drastic steps. This would require a setup which is not military engineered or technocrat but is composed of professionals regardless of their self and vested interest. Finally, the new leadership has a chance to be at the helm of affairs because general elections are due soon. Traditional political parties cannot deliver because of their corrupt and inept handing of affairs. It will be a good omen for the people of Pakistan if those candidates who are clean, educated and honest are able to reach assemblies and take appropriate damage control measures to save the country from further destruction.
Pakistan’s long standing predicament is the fact that things are not going in the right direction and whenever, the country is relatively stable something happens which derails the process of economic development and political stability. Even if foreign help announced in the recently held conference in Geneva is granted for reconstructing flood effected areas and for economic recovery, it will be a short term assistance. This is primarily because at the end of the day, perennial issues facing the country cannot be effectively dealt with unless there is a leadership at all the levels which is honest, competent, clear, hardworking and intelligent and can solely focus on social and human development, in place of protecting the interests, perks and privileges of the elite. On the contrary, Pakistan will further plunge into political schism, economic degeneration, extremism, intolerance, violence and terrorism.
Preventing the use of religion for political purposes is urgently needed because a lot of damage has already been done to Pakistan by misusing Islam and jihad for personal and political consumption. The youth of Pakistan, who is more than 60% of the population, will not have a plausible future unless it is ridden from orthodoxy and backwardness. An enlightened culture, based on tolerance and modernization of education, is the need of the hour. Paradigm shift in the priorities of elites and masses on critical issues engulfing Pakistan is essential.
The writer is Meritorious Professor of International Relations and former Dean Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Karachi and can be reached at amoonis@hotmail.com
Raza Rabbani calls for declaring 2023 ‘Year of Constitution’
GO Installs RO Plant
Cowasjee Institute to be made psychiatry university
PM approves outsourcing management of three key airports
Film on forced conversion bags international award
Veteran Journalist Mudassir Mirza passes away
NBP Awarded (GDEIB) Awards in four categories
Emirates Group returns to profit
American TV journalist Barbara Walters dies at 93
Faysal shifts to ‘Islamic only’ banking
Leave a Reply